Replay Sports Cards has awarded its first franchise agreement to business partners Josh Stigdon and Jason Buckel, paving the way for a new store in Seymour, Indiana. The signing marks the transformation of Replay from a regional operator into a national franchise system designed to bring modern card‑shop experiences to collectors across the country.
Stigdon and Buckel bring complementary backgrounds to the venture. Stigdon’s career as an attorney provides business discipline and compliance expertise, while Buckel’s experience in logistics and operations suits the demands of retail management. Their shared passion for the hobby and community connection drove their decision to lead Replay’s first franchise. “It feels incredible to be Replay’s first franchisees,” Stigdon said, adding that he looks forward to sharing the thrill of collecting with his children and the broader community.
The Seymour shop is envisioned as more than a retail store. Replay aims for it to serve as a local gathering place where collectors of all ages come together for trade nights, educational events, and social connection. Buckel described their vision as building a shop that welcomes both new collectors and long‑time hobbyists, with plans to partner with local schools and teams to embed the shop within the community fabric.
For Replay Sports Cards, the move into franchising underlines confidence in the trading‑card hobby’s resilience and growth amid rising demand for collectible and nostalgic experiences. As the hobby shifts into mainstream retail, this first franchise store may serve as a blueprint for future expansion. The Seymour opening offers early insight for prospective franchisees and industry observers interested in how niche retail sectors are adapting to new market trends.